For a Limited Time, Save 40% on the Skin Care Basics Kit plus Get Free Shipping with Any Order!
see details
Limited Time Only - Get the Skin Care Basics Kit for ONLY $25! Originally $42, Save 40% on the Skin Care Basics Kit (#51501) - no code required! Offer cannot be applied to previous purchases. Online only. Hurry, offer ends 11:59 PM PST 9/3/2015!

Free Shipping with No Minimum Purchase! Add products to cart and checkout to get FREE Standard Shipping (a $4.95 value). Canadian orders will receive $4.95 off the $14.95 Canadian Standard Shipping cost. Offer does not apply to play beautifully Box orders. Offer valid for a limited time only.

e.l.f.'s Guide to Eyeliner

Monday, September 17, 2012

There are MILLIONS of different eyeliners on the market today confusing us to the point of giving up! Fear not, we're here to tell you how to use them and what works best for you!

1. Kohl/Pencil: This is probably the easiest form of eyeliner and is used amongst beginners and experts! Kohl or Pencil eyeliners are applied by literally just drawing across your lash line. For a defined line, sharpen the pencil for a fresh pointed tip and line as close to the lash line as you can, carefully. Kohls are also great for creating smoky eyeliner or eyeshadow looks. Just apply the liner as you normally would and smudge it out with either your finger, a Q-Tip, or even a pencil brush. For more precise application or if you want to try a winged look, use an Eyeliner Brush to pick up some eyeliner from the Kohl/Pencil and line eyes with ease. Kohl/ Pencil Liner is also the most common used eyeliner for lining the upper and lower waterline (the line inside your eye). (Try our Shimmer Eyeliner Pencil in 'Blissful Blush' for a brightening effect)

2. Cream Eyeliner:  Cream Eyeliner is my personal favorite. This eyeliner is waterproof so no matter how you wear it, it will last without giving you raccoon eyes at the end of the night. Cream Eyeliner seems intimidating because you need to use it with a brush, but in my opinion it's the fastest and easiest eyeliner to use. All you need to do is pick up a little bit of the color on an Angled Brush or Eyeliner Brush (not too much!) and line the eyes carefully. The beauty of Cream Eyeliner is that it is more forgiving when applied, as opposed to Liquid Eyeliner. Cream Eyeliner can also be smudged out when applied to achieve a sultry, smoky look but make sure to smudge it immediately after you apply it because the product will stay put once it's dried. Cream Eyeliner can also be applied to the waterline and will probably last longer than Pencil/Kohl. Another added bonus- it can be used as a cream eyeshadow or an eyeshadow base when applied and blended with your fingers! Kudos for multi-functional products! (Try our Cream Eyeliner in 'Teal Tease' for a bright, fun look)

3. Liquid Eyeliner: Liquid Eyeliner is every beginners worst nightmare. Although it does achieve the most beautiful result in all eyeliner categories, Liquid Eyeliner takes patience and practice. This eyeliner in my opinion, takes the longest to apply. You need to steady your elbow on a table or desk, lean your head back and look down into a mirror and line in short smooth strokes to achieve a perfect line free of track marks (you know, those little marks you get when your eyeliner skips and leaves spots without eyeliner). This liner will give you the prettiest, smoothest, and darkest line you can ever get with an eyeliner. Some people even trace out their line with Cream or Powder eyeliner first and then go over it with Liquid Eyeliner to really make the eyes pop. I do NOT recommend using this eyeliner on the waterline as it will irritate your eyes. Also, steer clear of using this eyeliner on your lower lash line unless your a pro because it will not apply as smooth as the top lid. This is also the best eyeliner for creating a wing because the brush is made just for that! (Try our Liquid Eyeliner in 'Black' for high drama). 

4. Powder Eyeshadow: Eyeliner can actually be made from whatever eyeshadow you have laying around! Using a damp eyeliner brush or even a dry one, dip into powder eyeshadow and line your eyes as you would with any eyeliner. This gives a softer line to the eyes than a Cream or Liquid eyeliner would. This method of application ISN'T long wearing unless used with an eyeshadow primer. I used to apply dry eyeshadow as eyeliner every day for years because it was quick, didn't require precision, and looked so natural! (Try our Pigment Eyeshadow in 'Passionate Purple' for funky eyeliner)

5. Eyeliner Pen: This is the easier alternative to Liquid Eyeliner. You get the same defined effect, but with an easier application. All you do is take the cap off, and line the eyes with short strokes. The felt tip pen makes winging out eyes a breeze and is great for on-the-go application. I would NOT recommend using this eyeliner on the water line or lower lash line because it will irritate eyes and will not apply smoothly. Keep these eyeliners stored upside down in a cup to achieve maximum saturation. (Try our Waterproof Eyeliner Pen in 'Midnight' for effortless precision)

What formula of Eyeliner do YOU prefer and why? Tell us here!

Patti, contributing elfette

38 comments email to a friend print this page tags:
Digg Del Technorati feed FaceBook Faves FeedBurner Google MySpace StumbleUpon Twitter Yahoo

To reply to another userís comment directly, click on the Reply link in that comment box.

Click on the Thread link to expand a discussion stemming from that comment.
Trendjunkie wrote:
1) 9/17/2012 2:24:34 PM
I like allmethods of applying eyeliner and all types, but in order from fave to least fave it would be cream liner, then pencil, then a eyeliner pen and lastly the liquid(idk wat it is but i just cant get the hang of it. i like to apply it but some days it looks good and some days it doesnt) cream is so much easier and i LOOOVE LOVE LOVE ELF'S cream liner in all the colors, they are all sooo pigmented and uber creamy, its a dream for someone into you elf
Reply to this
ArianaB wrote:
2) 9/18/2012 2:01:16 PM
I am getting the essential eyeliner pen and I am hoping it's very pigmented because I want to create a thick eyeliner look.
Reply to this
LiisK wrote:
3) 9/19/2012 4:07:48 AM
e.l.f.'s cream liner is nice UNTIL IT DRIES. I have bought at least 6 that were half-dry by the time I got them. The packaging needs to be redesigned - contact with air is too much. Why has e.l.f. not used the same solution they have with the lip-balms? Inserting an extra seal under the cap is neither expensive nor troublesome.
Reply to this
Broke Gal in NYC wrote:
4) 9/21/2012 12:39:07 PM
I really love cream/gel eyeliner, but I haven't found the perfect eyeliner brush yet. My favorite is the ELF cream eyeliner in cooper, I wear it almost every day.
Reply to this
tarm wrote:
5) 9/21/2012 12:41:57 PM
liquid eyeliner! easy to go use, easy to smudge and easy to clean up mistakes! colors are brighter and bolder than a pencil!
Reply to this
Chloe.0 wrote:
6) 9/21/2012 12:42:31 PM
My personal favorite is kohl/pencil eyeliner. It is very easy to work with, for blending or achieving a crisp line. I usually layer eyeshadow of the same color directly over my liner, so the color really pops and lasts a long time!
Reply to this
princesspeach wrote:
7) 9/21/2012 12:42:57 PM
I absolutely LOVE the Cream Eyeliner. After seeing raves about it on YouTube, I decided I absolutely needed to try it. I don't regret buying it! It goes on so smooth, especially if I use my ELF Studio Angled Eyeliner brush. My favorite shade is Coffee--it goes with EVERYTHING!
Reply to this
brandyb wrote:
8) 9/21/2012 12:43:13 PM
OMG i love the Liquid eyeliner it stays well and do not have to reapply !!! THankx!!
Reply to this
ajw77 wrote:
9) 9/21/2012 12:43:18 PM
i just got the cream eyeliner a little over two weeks ago. i am in love!!! i've told a lot of my friends about it. i think it's the greatest out there!!!
Reply to this
queen_of_scribbles wrote:
10) 9/21/2012 12:44:39 PM
I love the liquid eyeliner pens, although cream shadow/liner is a close second. The best thing about the pens is that so many of them are very, very waterproof, so I don't have to worry about things getting smudgy. Something I've noticed is that the pens are starting to show up in different thicknesses, shapes, colors, et c. I love having all these choices!
Reply to this
Somethingnew wrote:
11) 9/21/2012 12:45:14 PM
I love the pen its easy to use my brides love it because they can take it with them and touch up if needed. :)
Reply to this
ELandonBreckenridge wrote:
12) 9/21/2012 12:47:25 PM
<3 Cream Eyeliner! Because it is easy to use. :)
Reply to this
phoebe eve wrote:
13) 9/21/2012 12:47:30 PM
my favorite is the cream eyeliner because it stays on no matter what! i can put it on in the morning right before school and leave it on all night when i'm hanging out with my friends. :) I wish i had it in every color!
Reply to this
morgn wrote:
14) 9/21/2012 12:47:46 PM
I'm a fan of kohl. I love my brown kohl pencils. They really give a nice natural look. Or I can go dramatic with my black liner and do a smokey look. I do own a few ELF creme liners and pens, but I always find myself going back to pencil for everyday use.
Reply to this
Lilyshine wrote:
15) 9/21/2012 12:49:01 PM
I am an eyeliner Pen FAN! I love them! I am a bit shaky, and that close to my eyes I like to have as much control as possible. I also love that I can draw one constant line. Not sharpening is also a plus!
Reply to this
makeupjunkie1 wrote:
16) 9/21/2012 12:52:11 PM
Reply to this
17) 9/21/2012 12:54:37 PM
I've always used liquid eyeliner and was kind if scared about trying out a cream, but I swear by this stuff now and wont use anything else.Its so easy to put on. Then, hung out and spent the night at a friends house. I rub my eyes, and everything, EVEN SLEPT and after 24 hours also, IT STILL LOOKED PERFECT. I didnt look like a raccoon zombie or anything in the morning. This stuff is amazing. Love it!!! Thanx ELF for such a gud product!
Reply to this
Chrashley87 wrote:
18) 9/21/2012 12:57:48 PM
I like liquid and cream best! Although I use Kohl for my wet line
Reply to this
Bonn wrote:
19) 9/21/2012 1:01:07 PM
Love the cream eye liners t stays on all day!!!
Reply to this
Breezy_shea wrote:
20) 9/21/2012 1:01:38 PM
I always reach for liquid! I find that because I have oily skin anything else smudges very easily. Plus I like the crisp lines & deep pigmentation you get with a liquid.
Reply to this
joey18_ wrote:
21) 9/21/2012 1:04:33 PM
My favourite eyeliner is Urban Decay's 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil. It'so smooth and it works amazingly on my sensitive skin!
Reply to this
kellshell wrote:
22) 9/21/2012 1:11:32 PM
I like to use eyeshadow with a damp eyeliner brush- it stays put and is softer looking... plus it gives me more color choices!
Reply to this
Lavish wrote:
23) 9/21/2012 1:11:52 PM
I'm fond of liquid liner. I'd like to try the pen but I feel like it would dry out like a marker` The only downside to the liquid liner is it's hard to clean between my eyelashes (and it drips on my eyelashes too!)~
Reply to this
poppyboo4 wrote:
24) 9/21/2012 1:11:52 PM
I previously use pencil, then noticed it tugs my lids, so I switched to liquid, but I'm still struggling with the precision.. I may just try the cream liner!
Reply to this
BookReader wrote:
25) 9/21/2012 1:12:55 PM
I like to use a pencil eyeliner because that seems to be the easiest to use. I also like using my eyeshadow line my eyes
Reply to this
emilyxnowhere wrote:
26) 9/21/2012 1:32:42 PM
My all time favorite eyeliner is my ELF eyeliner pen! I could never do my eyeliner properly until I bought my first black eyeliner pen.
Reply to this
rayro wrote:
27) 9/21/2012 1:34:28 PM
Eye shadow all the way! I only use shadows because harsh lines around my eyes, which protrude, are not flattering at all. I blend the shadows in as well to just create enough color and definition behind my lashes. Plus, who doesn't have loads of shadows always laying around to blend and create the perfect "liner" color?
Reply to this
photochick04 wrote:
28) 9/21/2012 1:38:14 PM
Liquid eyeliner is my favorite. I feel I get better application and a bolder line with the liquid. However, even though I don't like pencil E.F.L.'s Brightening Eyeliner has changed my mind. It goes on smooth with no tucking. I have been using that instead of my liquid eyeliner; as of late.
Reply to this
chochoney wrote:
29) 9/21/2012 2:58:52 PM
I like eyeliner pencils and cream eyeliner. It just seems as if I can control them better and they don't look harsh from the start.
Reply to this
TRex wrote:
30) 9/21/2012 3:28:14 PM
I like the cream liner, but I also like using an eyeliner brush with regular eyeshadows, especially when I want to get a shot of colour
Reply to this
Gianna<3 wrote:
31) 9/21/2012 6:59:29 PM
I looooove cream eyeliner because its easiest to apply for me! I love the elf cream eyeliners!!
Reply to this
happyrn wrote:
32) 9/21/2012 7:21:24 PM
I love elfs cream eyeliner in copper. It's the best eyeliner I've tried-so easy to apply and use. the color has just enough shimmer to accent without being over the top. I would love it if they could design the top to hold the brush, that would be wonderful!!
Reply to this
iowawellen wrote:
33) 9/21/2012 11:33:19 PM
I love the creme eyeliner. The brush is perfect; the eyeliner is super creamy and stays on all day. Can;t believe the value for the $$$
Reply to this
shana505 wrote:
34) 9/23/2012 10:33:48 AM
I use liquid eyeliner, I have used this for the past 13 years and love it. I've tried pecil eyeliners and pen eyeliners, I don't like the how pencil eyeliner can smudge and I have a hard time using the pen because of the felt tip.
Reply to this
shana505 wrote:
35) 9/23/2012 10:36:16 AM
I use liquid eyeliner, I have used this for the past 13 years and love it. I've tried pencil eyeliners and pen eyeliners, I don't like the how pencil eyeliner can smudge and I have a hard time using the pen because of the felt tip.
Reply to this
AnnetheCatDetective wrote:
36) 9/23/2012 7:13:44 AM
Personally, I love liquid eyeliner even though when it comes to liner I am more of a 'beginner'-- I'm way too flinchy about things near my sensitive eyes to use a pencil! I rarely wear eyeliner (because of that sensitivity, and because I'm about half-blind in one eye so it's hard to get liner even since those sensitive eyes can't handle contacts), but when I do, I've found my hand is steady enough that the liquid eyeliner I got in my last mystery bag gives me a great result. I've used a felt tip pen before, from a different company, when I was working a haunted house and needed an elaborate eye makeup for my graveyard ghoul look, and it was fine for its job, but I retired it quickly after, whereas I went out and bought a second liquid eyeliner after discovering how surprisingly easy it was for even a beginner to get the hang of.
Reply to this
Micky123321 wrote:
37) 9/30/2012 9:57:29 AM
I started out using pencil eyeliner first because it was the easiest to use and it lasted the longest for your $. Then I started using eyeliner on my top lid. I used a liquid eyeliner which was my biggest nightmare!! It smeared all over my lid and one time it got into my eye :( and then I got my elf CREAM eyeliner:) it was soo easy to apply it was mess-proof and me-proof;) And it lasts FOREVER.! I will NEVER use liquid eyeliner again.!
Reply to this
FridaPie! wrote:
38) 9/30/2012 5:15:23 PM
I love them all !
Reply to this

Live chat by BoldChat
e.l.f. RSS Feed elf Cosmetics blog RSS feed
elf Cosmetics
most popular

elf Cosmetics

elf Cosmetics
July 2015 (1)
June 2015 (3)
May 2015 (4)
April 2015 (4)
March 2015 (5)
February 2015 (1)
January 2015 (6)
December 2014 (4)
November 2014 (7)
October 2014 (15)
September 2014 (13)
August 2014 (11)
July 2014 (16)
June 2014 (18)
May 2014 (19)
April 2014 (18)
March 2014 (18)
February 2014 (10)
January 2014 (21)
December 2013 (5)
November 2013 (9)
October 2013 (18)
September 2013 (13)
August 2013 (13)
July 2013 (21)
June 2013 (12)
May 2013 (7)
April 2013 (22)
March 2013 (13)
February 2013 (14)
January 2013 (28)
December 2012 (8)
November 2012 (8)
October 2012 (16)
September 2012 (12)
August 2012 (13)
July 2012 (14)
June 2012 (21)
May 2012 (20)
April 2012 (23)
March 2012 (20)
February 2012 (15)
January 2012 (16)
December 2011 (13)
November 2011 (16)
October 2011 (16)
September 2011 (20)
August 2011 (16)
July 2011 (12)
June 2011 (11)
May 2011 (15)
April 2011 (12)
March 2011 (15)
February 2011 (15)
January 2011 (14)
December 2010 (8)
November 2010 (5)
October 2010 (9)
September 2010 (13)
August 2010 (18)
July 2010 (10)
June 2010 (18)
May 2010 (23)
April 2010 (22)
March 2010 (31)
February 2010 (21)
January 2010 (19)
December 2009 (15)
November 2009 (20)
October 2009 (18)
September 2009 (19)
August 2009 (14)
July 2009 (25)
June 2009 (25)
May 2009 (9)
April 2009 (8)
March 2009 (10)
February 2009 (6)
January 2009 (7)

elf Cosmetics
  • elf cosmetics UK site
  • elf cosmetics French Site
  • elf cosmetics Australia Site
  • elf cosmetics Spain Site
  • elf cosmetics Italy Site
  • elf cosmetics Netherlands Site
  • elf cosmetics Belgium Site
  • elf cosmetics Mexico Site
  • elf cosmetics Romanian Site
  • elf cosmetics Thailand Site
  • elf cosmetics Denmark Site
  • elf cosmetics Sweden Site
  • elf cosmetics Norway Site
  • elf cosmetics Swiss Site
  • PETA
  • Cruelty Free
  • PayPal Certified
SSL Certificate