e.l.f. Essential Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I owned this for a month or so and didn't like it. Then I decided to come on here and read reviews. I realized I wasn't using it right. I looked up how to properly tightline my upper lashes and tried the product again. I was very pleased with the results! It makes your lashes look fuller and makes you look like you have eyeliner on without people actually seeing a line on your lashes. It wasn't great for my bottom lashes, but I think this was worth the price if you want a more natural look without it being obvious you have makeup on.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I got this because I love to try new products from elf, I think recently they are on a roll.... then there's this product. The pen tip is wayyyy too hard for my eyelid I have sensitive skin so that may be it but its unbelievably hard feels like scratching on my eyelid so I have no idea how anyone would tightline with this. Secondly the liquid is super runny I will make the thinnest line and it will run into the inner corner of my eyelid which is annoying when all my make up is done. I just think this is not a very good product.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

The product itself I enjoyed. I used this to tightline my eyes. It was easy to apply and it stayed all day. I think the fact that it was hard worked well to ensure I can get between my lashes. The PROBLEM is that it works once or twice and then it stops working!!! The first one I used about 3x and then it stopped working. I tried to work with it a few more times and sometimes it would work sometimes it wouldn't. I then decided to purchase a second one hoping that I just got a dud or something. The second one was actually worse. I think I may have used it 1x and this time, no matter how much I worked with it, it wouldn't work back so that ended up in the trash. I wish it would just work b/c I actually enjoyed the product!!! ELF, please just fix the problem so I can purchase this affordable alternative!!!

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I picked this up at the store to replace my favorite pen liner,which they no longer carry. I am very disappointed. It was very difficult to apply and the line was very inconsistent. I wish they would bring back the basic pen liner.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I have have no space under my lashline for eyeliner and my lashes can be uneven on the top. This product is great in that I can dab the three tips down into my lashline instead of just dragging a line above it. It is an ingenious design. I also have a delicate and oily eyelid. I can skip primer with this product, the liner goes on with barely any pressure and remains dark.
I think this product is best for someone who wants a natural look not dramatic eyes and who may have a hard time applying traditional liner.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

1st I bought one black and coffee, and they dried up so easily. Then I tried is again and bought a 2nd one and they are doing pretty well now. So its a 50 50 chance if it ill dry up on you or not.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

If this is supposed to be for "tightlining" only, why the HECK is the regular eyeliner pen not being stocked? I left my eyeliner pen open and the felt tip dried out, so I figured I'd give this a try since it was the only liner in stock. Horrible. The tip is hard and scratches the skin. I don't know how they expect you to use a "heavier hand" without scratching your eyelid off. It wasn't long lasting, and itched my skin where I had tested it on my hand. I'm getting a refund ASAP. Very disappointed that my old liner is useless and I can't get a replacement for it apparently.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

So my store got rid of the old eyeliner pen , which I happen to love. I got this one. It is hard on the eye and it is difficult to use. It has the 3 line type of tip that is just worth less. I am not a fan.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I always buy the single tipped waterproof liquid liner and I love it. It doesn't last very long but the price is right and it last all day. I bought the triple tip because they were sold out of the other. I bought two so I would have a back up. One of them lasted for two applications then wore out and the other never delivered color. The tip was white when it came out of the box. Poor design. They need to trash this one.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Triple Tip Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I had no clue what type of liner this was. I actually purchased this liner because it is waterproof and the tip is short. I was looking for a more defined eyebrow without the makeup wearing off. It's great to use toward the tail of the eyebrows and then gently brush through the rest of the brows. Afterward, I finish the look with the clear eyebrow/mascara gel to seal and comb into the shape I want. Sometimes i just use it to define the outer eyebrows then fill with eye shadow. Like many of you girls I have been looking for the right shade, the right product, and so far I must say that this product is great and last a long time. I've only been using it for 1 week and no problems yet. So my observation is, YES it's a great buy, easy to use and love that the tip is hard and short to comb through my brows. " ELF PLEASE" make lighter brown colors and definitely try this tip out and do a video!!!