e.l.f. Essential Waterproof Eyeliner Pen

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

Ordinarily I live elf things, but this was a real miss. I was very excited when I bought it, but it was completely dry right out of the package. So dry that it literally would not make any sort of mark. Very dissappointing.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

Bought one plum & 1 coffee but were dried up on arrival. Complained and they very generously sent a replacement but those were dry too, couldn't get anything out of them no matter how I shake & apply. Ended up in my trash. just my luck?!

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

i loved the product for about the first week i had it. it went on easy and fast, but after a week or so i found some problems with it; the tip started to mess up and it did not last long as in i ran out of it very fast. over all i loved the product and i would buy it again if it lasted a little while longer.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I really loved this for everyday use! It is so easy to apply! I got one in black and one in brown. The brown color wasnt very pigmented, but I didn't need too strong of a color. The black looks very nice and is surprisingly well pigmented for a drugstore eyeliner! Sadly, I accidentally left the cap off of the black pen in my makeup bag, so it dried out. I always prefer pen liners to liquid liners because of how easy they are to apply. The biggest downside to these are that they do not wear for very long. They smudge easily on oily lids. The tip of the pen isn't the best quality and the very tip of the felt tends to fray a bit, but it doesn't affect the appearance.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

This prodct worked really well for me. It glided on smoothly and stayed there though out the day. I plan on buying this again!

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

This eyeliner was WAYYY to rough on my eyelids! Everytime I tried to put it on it actually hurt! I use it now to fill in some spaces i missed when I use E.L.F Liquid Eyeliner, which for me, I think is much better than this.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I've tried using this product and REALLY want to like it...the first few applications are easy, the pen glides beautifully, once it dries, it lasts all day, rain or shine! But the down side to this product is that it doesn't last very long, like as in, once you use this for a week at most, it dries up FAST and you have to upside-down it overnight to get every last ounce of it out, and even then, it's not a promise even application...
I love E.L.F. but this product needs to be worked on a bit more. Until the ink of the pen is able to last a bit longer, I'm going to have to stick to an eyeliner that I found at (of all places) the county fair that literally lasted a full year with no issue...E.L.F. if you can make this item to those standards, I will buy it by the dozens!!!

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I enjoy using the various colors offered of this liquid liner! It's also not flaky or messy like other liners I've tried in the past. I think this is a must buy.

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

I have tried about every eyeliner you can get, this is my all time favorite thing! I own it in every color. I am the kind of person who wears winged eyeliner everyday, and my life has become so simple with this product! I don't want to sound like I am over selling this but I can go to the gym, sweat my butt off and my eyeliner still looks amazing!
The only issue I have with this is, if you aren't careful putting the cap back on you can ruin the tip of the pen. It still works at that point, it just isn't as precise.
Other than that I will buy this until they stop making it!

Comments about elf Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen:

LOVE this product. I am terrible at putting on liquid liner, this is my solution. It's super easy to apply, stays on all day and has never worn away or smudged. It's easy to create whatever kind of look you're going for; I wear it daily to work and it's a go to for nights out.