REVIEW SNAPSHOT®
by PowerReviewsPros
- Easy to apply (61)
- Good value (58)
- Long lasting (56)
- Good pigmentation (46)
- Versatile (18)
Cons
- Messy (9)
- Difficult to apply (7)
- Stains easily (7)
- Flakes (6)
- Clumps (3)
Best Uses
- Daily use (52)
- Special occasions (27)
- Normal skin (17)
- Oily skin (14)
- Sensitive skin (12)
- Reviewer Profile:
- Natural style (26), Classic style (25), Trendy style (19)
- Skin Tone:
- Fair (42), Medium (27), Deep (6)
Reviewed by 76 customers
Sort by
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Good Value
- Long Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Daily Use
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
So this was a great product after trying one of their other mascaras and being a bit disappointed.
I love the brush with the ball at the tip. It's great for getting those tiny lashes on the inner eye.
It's a bit wet, so it's easy to get all over the place if you're not careful, and it doesn't dry really quickly, which is a bit of a hassle. But I will say it gives awesome length in no time. And it comes off easily in the shower or with a little water. It comes off like an extension mascara, so there's no smudging.
- Skin Tone:
- Medium
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Good Pigmentation
- Good Value
- Long Lasting
- Versatile
Cons
Best Uses
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
I love this mascara. I've tried everything from Revlon to a $14 Stila or Bad Gal Lash mascara and this is my fave. I usually get a waterproof formula, but this stays just as well. I really like the application, it gives great definition which is what I want!
- Skin Tone:
- Fair
Pros
- Clever Brush Shape
- Easy To Apply
- Smooth application
Cons
- Flakes
- Gets Gummy
- Will Not Come Off
Best Uses
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
I really wanted to love this. The application is smooth, and I loved how the rounded tip of the brush got to lashes that otherwise might not get covered.
However, I had the worst time when it came to removal. I tried three different products to remove it, including a waterproof makeup remover, and NOTHING took it off. All it did was get gummy and flake, which continued to get in my eyes the next day! I tried it a second time, thinking I had overreacted, but no. Again, three different removal products, and nothing worked. It did get gummy enough that I could pick it off with my fingernails.
- Skin Tone:
- Fair
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Good Pigmentation
- Good Value
- Long Lasting
Cons
- None
Best Uses
- Daily Use
- Normal Skin
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
Being schooled in Makeup Artistry I may have a slight advantage using Mascara, maybe not. Regardless, I love this product, and the wand! I always remove excess product from the wand, and gently lifting the eyelid apply from the root to the tip, this wand is great for this method. It also seperates wonderfully and does lower lashes equally well. I did not note ANY racoon effect using this mascara and that's always been a problem for me. I use several mascara's personally, and this one has made the cut into my makeup case along with two others.
- Skin Tone:
- Medium
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Good Value
- Long Lasting
Cons
Best Uses
- Daily Use
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
love this product. my new fav mascara
- Skin Tone:
- Deep
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Good Pigmentation
- Good Value
- Long Lasting
Cons
- Flakes
Best Uses
- Daily Use
- Special Occasions
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
This mascara is so amazing (especially considering the price!) I can fall asleep in this, and my lashes will still be beautiful the next day - that's how long it lasts. Occasionally, you might get some tiny flakes which wipe away easily.
I'm a new dedicated customer of this product!
- Skin Tone:
- Fair
Pros
- Awesome Brush
- Easy To Apply
- Good Pigmentation
- Great Formula
- Versatile
Cons
- Messy
Best Uses
- Glamorous Nights
- Special Occasions
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
I use this product when their is a fancy party coming up. I would wear this with bright colors. It realy does what its meant to do it lengthens, defines, and volumizes.The only thingthats not so special about it is its a bit messy, anytime i use it i will occasionally get mascara on my eyelids. even if im oh so carefull because it really does lengthen all the way to touch even your eyelids.
- Skin Tone:
- Medium
Pros
- Easy To Apply
Cons
Best Uses
- Daily Use
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
Would be a good mascara for a more "natural" look, but I guess I've just been spoiled by Benefit "they're real" mascara. I like big, bold lashes, and this just doesn't deliver.
- Skin Tone:
- Medium
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Good Pigmentation
- Good Value
Cons
Best Uses
- Daily Use
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
I love this mascara. Its a great product for a great price!! I bought this thinking I would just give it a shot, and my hopes weren't really all that high, even though I am ELF's biggest supporter and best sales person, lols.
Well anyway. I bougth this and could not wait to try it. I put it on it the car and holy goodness, I have yet to meet a mascara that made me as happy as this one. The brush grabs each lash and pulls it to its best lenghth and it seperates beautifully. I love the little ball to get those tiny lashes in the inner corner of my eye, and the thinner part gets every single one of my lower lashes perfectly.
The only thing that I might tweek is the color. Its not the blackest mascara I've ever used. But its still a good black color. I think its a great every day mascara.
Just a tip, when you put this on, do one eye with one layer, and then go to the other to let the first get a little tacky. After that go back to the first and swipe on another layer. Do the same to the other eye. Do this as many times as you like. You can build length and volume this way. But you have to let it get tacky or it doesn't work!!
Good luck peeps!!
- Skin Tone:
- Fair
Pros
- Easy To Apply
- Good Pigmentation
- Good Value
- Long Lasting
- Versatile
Cons
Best Uses
- Daily Use
- Normal Skin
- Special Occasions
Comments about elf Cosmetics 3-in-1 Mascara:
I purchased this for the first time months ago. I was accustomed to spending $6+ on mascaras. I have thick eyelashes so I go through a lot of mascara.
The first thing I noticed about ELF's mascara was that it truly made a difference.
After I ran out, I ordered more but had to go back to my "before" mascara. My eye lashes were flat in comparison.
I'm sticking to this.
- Skin Tone:
- Fair
Displaying reviews 1-10
Previous | Next »





































